
Neighbor tree disputes in Belgium can arise when someone plants or lets several trees grow well above two meters tall, less than two meters from the boundary with the property next door. If this happens to you, the trees may partially block sunlight, affecting your comfort, your solar panels’ output, the natural light in your home or the growth of your own plants. In fall, large amounts of leaves may also land on your property, leaving you with regular cleanup work. Here are your options and rights when dealing with your neighbor.
Neighbor tree disputes in Belgium: requesting removal
Your first option is to request that the trees be uprooted. In principle, trees planted too close to the boundary must be removed. The law is relatively clear on this point: when the legal planting distances are not respected, the affected neighbor can demand that the situation be brought into compliance. Strictly speaking, you do not even have to prove that the trees cause an actual nuisance or specific harm. Failure to respect the legal distance may be enough to support your request.
If you fear that your neighbor will not comply with a court order to remove the trees, you can also ask the judge to attach a financial penalty for non-compliance (astreinte) to the judgment. Your neighbor would then have to pay a sum for each day of non-compliance or each breach of the order. If you have suffered actual, measurable harm, such as cleanup costs, a loss in your property’s value or proven damage, you can also claim compensation alongside removal.
The judge may choose a less drastic solution
The judge does not automatically have to order the trees’ removal. Depending on the specific circumstances of the case, they may propose a less drastic solution. For example, if the judge considers that pruning or regular trimming would already significantly reduce the nuisance, they could impose that alternative. The dispute would then be resolved through an obligation to trim the trees rather than remove them entirely.
The judge therefore has some discretion and will, where possible, seek to balance both parties’ interests. They will consider the specific situation, the trees’ actual impact and the broader neighborhood context.
Abuse of rights
Your neighbor could also invoke abuse of rights (abus de droit) to try to have your request rejected. Under this legal principle, exercising a right can be considered abusive when it goes beyond what is reasonable. If your neighbor can show that the benefit you seek is clearly disproportionate to the harm they would suffer, the judge could refuse to order removal.
One example would be a tree planted only a few centimeters short of the required legal distance, without causing any significant nuisance. In such a case, the judge might consider a demand to uproot the tree an abuse of rights and favor a more nuanced solution, or even reject the request.