Skip to main content

Unpaid subcontractor rights in Belgium: direct claims

On a construction project, the main contractor often assigns some or all of the work to one or more subcontractors. When everyone meets their obligations, things run smoothly. But if the contractor stops paying, tensions can quickly rise. A subcontractor who has completed the work properly faces a very real risk: working without being paid. Unpaid subcontractor rights in Belgium include a particularly effective remedy: a direct claim (action directe).

Construction work

Unpaid subcontractor rights in Belgium: payment by the client

This claim is provided for in Article 1798 of the old Civil Code (Code civil), and its general mechanism is now enshrined in Article 5.110 of the new Civil Code. It allows an unpaid subcontractor to demand payment directly from the client (maître d’ouvrage), meaning the person who entered into the contract with the main contractor. The client pays the subcontractor as if paying the main contractor.

Take a simple example. You are renovating your home and sign a contract with a general contractor. That contractor subcontracts the roofing, heating or electrical work, for example. The work is completed, but the subcontractor is never paid. If the subcontractor acts in time, they can demand payment directly from the client, meaning you, up to the amount you still owe the main contractor.

However, the client can raise against the subcontractor any defenses they could have raised against the main contractor, as well as any defenses the main contractor could have raised against the subcontractor, provided their basis predates the exercise of the direct claim.

If a disagreement persists, the law allows the client to deposit the disputed funds for safekeeping (consignation) with the Deposit and Consignment Office (Caisse des dépôts et consignations) or in a blocked account, pending an agreement or a court decision. This avoids the risk of paying the wrong party. Depositing the funds becomes mandatory if either the main contractor or the subcontractor requests it in writing.

Making a direct claim is relatively straightforward

One of the main advantages of a direct claim is that it is relatively straightforward to exercise. It can be made out of court, notably by registered mail.

Of course, if the client refuses to pay for any reason, the subcontractor will need to start court proceedings to obtain an enforceable title (titre exécutoire), which allows compulsory recovery of the money if necessary.

Even so, exercising a direct claim offers a relatively simple way to freeze the sums the client owes the main contractor. This gives the subcontractor’s claim a degree of protection, particularly against the effects of the contractor’s possible insolvency.

The limits of a subcontractor’s direct claim

This remedy does have its limits.

A subcontractor can never claim more than they are owed. Nor can they recover more than the client still owes the contractor when the direct claim is exercised. In other words, if the client has already paid the contractor in full before receiving valid notice of the claim, a direct claim will often lose much of its value. Conversely, a client who ignores a direct claim that has been validly notified risks having to pay a second time, this time to the subcontractor.

A direct claim can no longer be initiated once a situation involving competing creditors’ claims (concours) has opened, such as the contractor’s bankruptcy (faillite). Insolvency difficulties can quickly make matters more complicated, although a contractor’s judicial reorganization (réorganisation judiciaire) does not, in principle, prevent a direct claim based on Article 1798.

The client’s direct recourse against a subcontractor

The client also has recourse against the subcontractor.

Since Book 6 of the Civil Code entered into force on January 1, 2025, and more specifically under Article 6.3, § 2, the client can now, under certain conditions, seek to hold the subcontractor directly liable for fault in carrying out the work. This is not a direct payment claim like the subcontractor’s claim under Article 1798, but a non-contractual claim. This mechanism can be particularly useful when the main contractor fails to meet their obligations or is insolvent.

Why timing matters

A subcontractor’s direct claim is a powerful remedy because, in some cases, it allows them to bypass the main contractor and seek payment at its source, from the client. Its effectiveness depends on knowing that the remedy exists and using it correctly, while there is still time to act. Even a few days of inaction can sometimes change the outcome.

This article is for information only and does not constitute legal advice. For any specific question, consult a legal professional.

Raffaele Petrullo, lawyer at the Brussels and Luxembourg Bars (www.astralis-law.be | 02 705 57 47 | info@astralis-law.be).

Written by

Jean Philippe Roisin

Content Expert

Jean-Philippe Roisin has been working in digital marketing and content creation, serving as the Digital Marketing Manager at Immovlan.be since January 2018. Living in Brussels, Belgium, he has contributed to the content development of Gocar.be and Immovlan.be, aiming to improve audience engagement through digital content. Jean-Philippe is also the owner of Good to Great, a role he has held since January 2011, where he supports various businesses, from startups to established companies, in reaching their digital marketing objectives. His time at Gocar.be, until December 2020, coincided with a period of growth for the platform, helping to enhance its position in Belgium's automotive industry.