Carport vs. garage: which is the best choice for your vehicle?

When it comes to safeguarding your vehicle, the choice between a carport and a garage might seem straightforward. However, there’s more to consider than meets the eye. Whether you’re building a new home, renovating, or simply adding to your existing property, the decision is crucial. Let’s delve into the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed choice.


Security: Garage Takes the Lead

When it comes to security, garages have a clear edge. Under a carport, your vehicle remains visible, offering little to no protection against potential intruders. On the other hand, a garage provides a secure environment, even allowing for the installation of alarms. If the garage is integrated into the main house, the security level is even higher. This protection extends not only to your vehicle but also to any gardening or DIY tools you might store there.

Costs: Carport Wins on Affordability

In terms of cost, carports, with their simpler design, are undeniably more affordable than garages, especially brick-built ones. A DIY enthusiast can set up a decent carport for just over 1000 euros. In contrast, a garage, especially one integrated into the house, requires a significantly larger budget.

Usability: A Tie Between Carport and Garage

Carports offer unparalleled ease of use, with no doors to open or close and virtually unlimited width. Maintenance is also simpler, especially for wooden structures. However, an integrated garage with an automated door offers the ultimate convenience. It shields you from the elements when entering or exiting your vehicle, ensuring a warmer car in winter and a cooler one in summer.

Construction Ease: Carport Takes the Crown

The carport’s simplistic design makes it easier to install than a garage, especially a brick-built one. With no need for doors, insulation, or complex roofing, and minimal foundational requirements, carports also occupy less space than garages.

Corrosion Risk: It’s a Draw

Contrary to popular belief, carports can better prevent corrosion risks than garages. While they shield vehicles from harsh weather, the open design allows wind to dry the vehicle quickly. However, for classic cars or weekend treasures that rarely face rain, a garage remains the top choice. A heated garage is the gold standard, but if that’s out of reach, a sealed wooden structure is ideal due to its natural humidity-fighting properties.

Urban Planning Permissions: A Level Playing Field

Both carports and garages may be exempt from urban planning permissions under specific conditions. It’s essential to consult local regulations, which typically consider factors like maximum area, roof type, height, and the structure’s location.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

A simple tally of the above criteria might suggest that carports have an edge over garages. However, the best choice largely depends on individual needs. Carports are perfect for everyday vehicles, especially when adding to an existing structure. They’re easy, efficient, and cost-effective, gaining popularity among homeowners. Yet, nothing can match the security and versatility of a garage, especially for safeguarding both vehicles and other valuable equipment.